The Love Story that Built St. Mary Catholic Church

Men of the cloth frequently juggle multiple roles: head of the church, community spiritual leader, and faith counselor, among others. But Father Anthony Scheideler, a Catholic priest in Indianapolis, also became a matchmaker. His role in introducing renowned architect Herman Gaul to his future wife would pay godly dividends.

St. Mary Catholic Church is an architectural gem. Its gothic towers help define the downtown Indianapolis skyline, while its bells call the faithful to worship. Not only for its congregation but also for those dining and shopping in the Mass Ave. cultural district, the cathedral provides a glimmer of stately beauty nestled amid the urban landscape. But St. Mary’s is more than just an elegant building. It is the physical testament to a love story—one set into motion by a kind, matchmaking priest.

Episode written by Jill Weiss Simins, edited by Michella Marino, hosted by Justin Clark, and produced by A.J. Chrapliwy. Transcript and source notes available at https://podcast.history.in.gov/.